A Comment On Children and Failure

A Facebook friend of mine recently posted the following quote:

Where did we ever get the crazy idea that in order to make children do better, first we have to make them feel worse? Think of the last time you felt humiliated or treated unfairly. Did you feel like cooperating or doing better?

Jane Nelson

I was curious about this statement.  What I infer from her quote is that someone, somewhere believes humiliating people, and treating them unfairly is a formula for positive results.  On the contrary, neither of these two behaviors seem to lend to a positive outcome.  How someone would come to believe that others actually do this intentionally is confusing to me.

“Did you feeli like cooperating or doing better?”  No, I would not feel like cooperating or doing better.  I would feel like going somewhere else, where there are other people who aren’t manipulative, using humiliation to attempt to mold someone into what they want them to be, rather than what they were designed to be.

I’m making an assumption, but I believe that this quote is in reference to overcoming failure, which is a huge sore spot for me, when it comes to raising children, of which I have none.  I do have common sense, however.

If we protect our children from failure, they will not learn to survive on their own.  When they enter the real world, they will soon discover how much they have been trained to behave like a victim when things don’t go “fairly” for them.

If, we push our children into failure, and we intentionally humiliate them, then we are doing as much damage as if we were to allow them not to fail by manufacturing “fair” environments.

One of the most recent examples of “fair” that I can think of was a story of a neighborhood easter egg hunt.  A few kids found most of the eggs, some of the kids found some of the eggs, and a large group of kids found nothing.  A parent who protested managed to convince the rest of the neighborhood parents to take all of the eggs from all of the children and divide them evenly amongst each other.

For those children who failed to collect any eggs, what lesson have we taught them?  Isn’t it more detrimental to their future to falsely impress upon them that it’s impossible to be knocked off the proverbial “horse” in life?  Don’t we want them to understand “getting right back on that horse?”

If a child puts his or herself in a situation which requires hard work to achieve a goal, such as joining a soccer team, or being part of a choir, let them experience failure, so the next time they try, when they work harder to achieve their goal, and they succeed at what they previously failed at, their achievement will be sweeter, and will build self-confidence.  Let them try and let them fail.  But don’t force them to fail, and do all of it in love.

Eyegazing: Overcoming Feelings of Insecurity

sexystareThe exercise of locking eye to eye with a complete stranger, intentionally, and holding until they break away, is one of those activities that will help you gain self confidence as you are introduced to the shockingly ignored concept that everyone else is just as insecure as you are.  As you do this, you will find that your self confidence will immediately receive a boost of energy.

Timothy Ferris in The Four Hour Work Week, Escape 9-5, Live Anywhere, And Join the New Rich, talks about this as one of those critical exercises that will help you build self confidence and move you closer to greater success in the pursuit of your Entrepreneurship.

Sitting in Hava Java today, as people meander through, I have taken a few opportunities to lock eyes with people as they walk in.  Most people are immediate in how quickly they divert their gaze somewhere else, for who knows what reason.  Perhaps they don’t like looking at me, perhaps they’re insecure about being looked at, or perhaps they are just in their own world and don’t notice.  A large percentage of the people walking in have sunglasses on, so it makes the exercise impossible, but for those who come in sporting shiny, exposed, eyes, little do they know the trap that I have set.

I’ll have to admit, it’s extremely difficult to fight the temptation to look away first, but so rewarding when you conquer the fear.  Don’t try doing it with the same person twice, unless you intend to start up a conversation, which wouldn’t be that bad anyway would it?  And, if someone feels uncomfortable enough the first go-around to approach you and ask you what your problem is, as Ferris states, just tell them “I’m sorry, I thought you were an old friend of mine.”

My recent encounter was with a woman who walked in.  I locked on to her eyes and held.  It was difficult, but I did it, and she looked away.  It was at this point that I continued to hold the look.  What happened next was completely unexpected.  She looked again, and then I could really tell she was nervous.  I could also tell that she understood that I had established the upper hand in the exchange and I was the initiator, which boosted my confidence and gave me options.

I will continue to exercise this, and I would recommend that you give it a shot too!  It’s a great feeling to overcome insecurity when you realize you’re not the only one who feels insecure.

No one is a failure until he thinks he is

Arcticle originally printed in the Arizona Republic by Harvey Mackay:

Have you ever heard the old fable about when the devil offered all the tools of his trade to anyone who would pay their price? They were spread out on the table, each one labeled — hatred, malice, envy, despair and sickness — all the weapons that everyone knows so well. But off on one side apart from the rest, lay a harmless-looking, wedge-shaped instrument marked discouragement. it was old and worn-looking, but it was priced far above all the rest. When asked why, the devil explained: “Because I can use this one so much more easily than the others. No one knows that it belongs to me, so with it I can open doors that are tightly bolted against the others. Once I get inside, I can use any tool that suites me best.”

A very real problem within all of us that can cause an attitude crash is discouragement. I’ve always gone out of my way to stay away from negative people. I like to surround myself with positive, upbeat people who constantly encourage me.

How can you reach for the stars, go bravely where no man has gone before or climb the highest mountain if you’re discouraged?

Author Glenn Van Ekeren outlines the four pitfalls of discouragement: Discouragement hurts our self-image; causes us to see ourselves as less than we really are; causes us to blame others for our predicament; and causes us to blur the facts.

Dale Carnegie, the eternal optimist, said: “Tell a child, a husband or an employee that he is stupid or dumb at a certain thing, that he has no gift for it, and that he is doing it all wrong and you have destroyed almost every incentive to try to improve. But use the opposite technique, be liberal with encouragement; make the thing seem easy to do, let the other person know that you have faith in his ability to do it, that he has an undeveloped flair for it, and he will practice until the dawn comes in at the window in order to excel.”

One of the greatest novels in American literature was the result of a very discouraging day for the author. Nathaniel Hawthorne had lost his job at a customhouse and went home to break the new to his wife, Sophia. Rather than the reaction he expected she was joyous. “Now you can write your book,” she told him.

Unconvinced, Hawthorne asked her, “And what shall we live on while I am writing it?”

Sophia opened a drawer, which contained a substantial amount of money and told him, “I have always kown that you were a man of genius. I knew that someday you would write a masterpiece.” She went on to explain that she had saved some of the household money each week, and had accumulated enough to last for a year. And with that, Hawthorne set to work on The Scarlett Letter, a novel many of us have read in our high school English classes. And all because Sophia Hawthorne refused to let her husband he discouraged.

In her book The Right Words at the Right TIme, Marlo Thomas tells the story of Shaquille O’Neal, now the superstar center for the NBA’s Miami Heat. When he was 14, he attended a basketball camp expecting to astound the coaches with his brilliance. He had been a star in his San Antonion high school, but at the camp he was just one of many star athletes. Not getting the attention he was accustomed to from the coaches, he began to worry that perhaps he wasn’t good enough to make the grade. His self-confidence took a nosedive.

Discouraged, he turned to his parents for advice. His mother told him: “You must fulfuill your dreams while there’s still room for you to do so. Attack them with a full head of steam. There’s no opportunity like now. This is the time you can show people.”

His confidence almost gone, Shaq told his mother, “I can’t do that right now. Maybe later.” Then, says Shaq, his mother said the words that he remembers changed his life: “Later doesn’t always come to everybody.”

Mackay’s Moral: You aren’t finished when you are defeated; you are finished when you quit.